Practice Before You Go
To get a better car deal, get a written out-the-door price first. Talk about the total price, not the monthly payment. Keep your trade-in separate. Say no to add-ons you did not ask for. Be ready to leave. Practice what you will say before you go.
Quick Answer
To get a better car deal, get a written out-the-door price first. Talk about the total price, not the monthly payment. Keep your trade-in separate. Say no to add-ons you did not ask for. Be ready to leave. Practice what you will say before you go.
How it works
- Learn the moves: Read seven short cards. Each one has the words to say.
- Practice by typing: Pick a scene. A pretend dealer talks. You answer, or tap a real buyer question. Then you get tips.
- Take your script: Print it or email it to yourself. Bring it with you.
1. Learn the moves
Get a written out-the-door price first
The out-the-door price is the total you pay, with tax and fees. A number on paper is hard to change later.
Say: "Please email me the out-the-door price for this car, with every fee listed."
Talk about the total price, not the payment
A low payment can hide a high price or a long loan. The total tells the truth.
Say: "I'm not shopping by payment. What is the total price?"
Keep the trade-in separate
When the trade and the new car are mixed, it is hard to see if you got a fair deal on either.
Say: "Let's agree on the car price first. Then we can talk about my trade."
Say no thanks to add-ons you did not ask for
Extras like coatings, etching or service plans can be added to the price. Most are optional.
Say: "Please take off anything I did not ask for and show me the new total."
On a lease, get every number in writing
A lease payment is built from the price, the residual, the money factor and fees. You can only check what you can see.
Say: "Please write down the price, money factor, residual and every fee."
Price first, rebate second
A carmaker rebate is yours at any dealer. If you mention it first, the dealer may call it their discount.
Say: "Is that price before or after the carmaker rebate? Please show me your discount on its own line."
Be ready to leave
Leaving is a move, not a failure. Another car and another day will come.
Say: "Thank you. I need to think about it. Here is my number if the price changes."
2. Practice by typing
Pick a scene. A pretend dealer (an AI) talks first. You get five replies, then tips. Any numbers it uses are pretend, made up for practice, not real prices, rates or fees. It never names a real dealer.
The salesperson
Your goal: Steer the talk to the total out-the-door price, in writing.
Real questions buyers ask here:
- What is the out-the-door price, in writing?
- This is the total you pay. It has the car price, tax, title, and every fee. Ask for it by email or on paper before you talk about payments.
- Can I just tell you the monthly payment I want?
- It is better not to. A payment can be made low by a longer loan or a higher price. Agree on the total price first.
- What is this doc fee, and can it come down?
- A doc fee pays for paperwork. Some states limit it. Ask what it is and look up your state's rule. You can ask for the car price to drop to make up for it.
- Is there a market adjustment or added sticker?
- Some cars have a second sticker with extra dealer charges. Those are set by the dealer, not the carmaker. Ask what each line is and if it can come off.
- Is the destination charge real?
- Yes. The carmaker sets it, and it is on the window sticker. Check that it is only charged once.
- Is that price before or after the carmaker rebate?
- A rebate comes from the carmaker, not the dealer. Agree on the dealer's own price first. Then ask for the rebate to come off after, on its own line.
- What is your discount, not counting the rebate?
- The rebate comes from the carmaker, so you would get it at any dealer. Ask what the dealer itself is taking off. That is the part you negotiate.
- Which rebates do I qualify for, and what is the end date on each?
- Check the carmaker's site with your ZIP code before you go. Some rebates are only for loyal owners, people switching brands, military or new grads. Write down each end date.
- Can I get the rebate and the low rate together?
- Sometimes you must pick one. Ask which ones stack. If you must choose, compare the total cost of each, using your own pre-approved rate.
- Please show me the total with cash back and the total with the low rate.
- Ask for both on paper. Compare the total you pay over the whole loan, not the monthly payment. Bring your own pre-approved rate to compare.
- Is the car in the ad really here, at that price?
- Ask for the VIN and a written quote before you go. If the price is different when you get there, ask why in writing.
- Does the FTC rule make dealers show the full price?
- The FTC wrote a rule called the CARS Rule, but a federal court threw it out in January 2025. So ask for the full price yourself. Your state may still have its own rules.
The trade-in offer
Your goal: Keep the trade-in separate and ask for the offer on paper.
Real questions buyers ask here:
- What will you give me for my trade, on its own?
- Ask for the trade offer as its own number on paper. When the trade is mixed into the payment, it is hard to see if it is fair.
- I may have a trade. Can we agree on the car price first?
- You can wait. Agree on the price of the new car first. Then talk about the trade.
- I owe more than my car is worth. What happens?
- That is called negative equity. If it is added to the new loan, you pay for your old car inside the new one. Ask to see it as its own line.
- After you pay off my loan, how much will I still owe? I may pay that part in cash.
- Get the payoff and the trade offer side by side. Pay the gap in cash so it does not go into a new loan. Then buy a cheaper car with cash, or keep paying until your car is paid off.
- Will you pay off my old loan?
- Many dealers say they will. Get it in writing, and check with your old lender that the payoff was made.
- How did you get that number? I want to compare it with other offers.
- Get offers from other buyers before you go. Then you have a number to compare.
The finance office
Your goal: Ask what each extra costs in total, and say no to what you do not want.
Real questions buyers ask here:
- What is in the protection package?
- It is a bundle of extras. It may have a service contract, GAP, tire and wheel cover, paint or fabric coating, and key cover. Ask for a list with the total price of each one.
- Is an extended warranty the same as the factory warranty?
- No. An "extended warranty" is usually a service contract you pay extra for. The factory warranty comes with a new car. Read what the contract covers and who pays for repairs.
- Do I have to buy add-ons to get the loan?
- Add-ons are optional. If someone says the loan needs one, ask to see that in writing from the lender.
- What is GAP, and do I need it?
- GAP pays the gap between what insurance pays and what you still owe if the car is totaled or stolen. It may help if you owe more than the car is worth. It is optional, and you can often buy it elsewhere.
- It's only a few dollars a month. Why not?
- A few dollars a month for 72 months adds up. Ask for the total cost of each item, not the monthly amount.
- Can I take an add-on off after I sign?
- Many service contracts and GAP plans can be canceled for a partial refund. Read the cancel terms before you sign, and ask how the refund works.
- Can I get the price with and without the extras?
- Yes. Ask to see the payment and total cost both ways. Then you can see what each extra really adds.
- What APR did the lender approve, and is there a markup?
- Dealers can add to the rate a lender offers. Get pre-approved at a bank or credit union first. Then ask the dealer to beat that rate in writing.
- Can you make the loan longer to lower my payment?
- Yes, but a longer loan costs more in interest. You may also owe more than the car is worth for longer. Look at the total cost.
- What is the total I will pay over the loan?
- Ask for the amount financed, the finance charge and the total of payments. These are on your loan papers.
- Is my loan final before I drive home?
- Ask this out loud. Some dealers let you drive home before the loan is final. Later they may call and ask you to sign a worse deal. You do not have to accept a new deal.
- Is there a penalty if I pay the loan off early?
- Ask, and look for it in the contract. Know the answer before you sign.
- Can I bring my own loan?
- Yes. A pre-approval from a bank or credit union lets you compare. You can still let the dealer try to beat it.
- Do I have to buy car insurance from you?
- You need insurance, but you can usually get it anywhere. Get your own quote before you go. If they say you must use theirs, ask to see that rule in writing.
- Is your insurance cheaper than mine?
- Maybe. A dealer agent only shows the companies it works with. Compare the same coverage and the six-month cost.
- Is there any insurance added to my loan?
- Ask about force-placed, CPI or VSI insurance. These protect the lender, not you. Ask if the charge can come off when you show your own policy.
- What happens if I do not have insurance today?
- The lender may buy force-placed insurance and charge you. It protects only the lender and usually costs much more. Get your own quote on your phone first.
The lease desk (upside-down trade)
Your goal: Ask to see the old debt as its own line, and the price, money factor, residual and fees.
Real questions buyers ask here:
- What is the price (cap cost) on this lease?
- The cap cost is the price of the car in the lease. You can talk it down, like a purchase. Ask for it in writing.
- What is the money factor?
- It is the lease's interest rate in a different form. Times 2,400 gives a rough APR. Ask for the number, not just the payment.
- What is the residual?
- It is what the car should be worth at the end. The lease papers must show it. A higher residual often means a lower payment.
- Is there lease cash on this car, and is it in this price?
- Lease cash is money from the carmaker that only works on a lease. It should lower the cap cost. Ask to see it on its own line.
- What fees are in this lease?
- Ask about the start fee, end-of-lease fee, extra-mile charge and wear charges. Lease papers must show these.
- Can I roll my old car debt into a lease?
- You can, but you still pay that debt, plus rent charge on it. Ask to see the old debt as its own line.
- If I keep this lease to the end, is my old car debt gone?
- Yes, with a standard closed-end lease. The old debt is paid inside your monthly payments. Keep the full term, stay under the miles, and turn it in. Then you owe only end fees and any wear or mile charges.
- What if I end the lease early?
- Ending early can cost a lot. The lease papers must explain how the early-end charge works. Read it first.
The used car lot (sold as is)
Your goal: Ask for the Buyers Guide, your own mechanic's check and a recall check before you agree.
Real questions buyers ask here:
- Can I see the Buyers Guide? Is it sold as is?
- Dealers must post a Buyers Guide on used cars. It says if the car has a warranty or is sold as is. Keep a copy.
- Can my own mechanic check the car?
- The Buyers Guide tells you to ask. A good seller should say yes. If they say no, think hard about why.
- Are there open recalls on this car?
- Look up the VIN on the free NHTSA recall site. Ask the dealer to fix open recalls before you buy.
- Can I return the car if I change my mind?
- Usually no. The federal cooling-off rule covers door-to-door sales, not car buys at a dealer. Some dealers offer a return policy. Get it in writing.
- Can I take the papers home to read?
- Ask for copies of every page before you sign. Every blank should be filled in. Do not sign until the numbers match your quote.
All answers, with sources: questions to ask a car dealer.
3. Take your script
Print your what-to-say lines or email them to yourself. Leasing with an upside-down trade? Read using a lease to get out.
Common questions
How do I negotiate a car price?
Get a written out-the-door price first. Talk about the total, not the payment. Keep your trade separate. Say no to extras. Be ready to leave.
Is the practice dealer a real person?
No. It is an AI that plays a pretend dealer. Any numbers it uses are made up for practice. They are not real prices. It never names a dealer.
Do I have to sign up?
No. The practice is free. You only give your email if you want your script sent to you.
Can I practice a lease when I'm upside down?
Yes. Pick the lease desk scene. It helps you ask to see the old debt as its own line.
What should I say in practice?
Type your own words, or tap one of 48 real questions buyers ask. Each one has a short, checked answer you can read.
What if I get nervous at the dealer?
Bring your script. Read it out loud. It is fine to say you need to think and leave.